Club Profiles

AFC Bournemouth club badge
Arsenal
Aston Villa Club badge
Brentford badge
Brighton and Hove Albion club badge
Burnley FC club badge
Chelsea club badge
Crystal Palace badge
Everton
Liverpool badge
Manchester City badge
Manchester United badge
Newcastle United club badge
Nottingham Forest club badge
Sheffield United badge
Spurs badge
West Ham United
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Taken off for treatment.

Taken off for Treatment

Taken off for Treatment

A defender goes down injured, and you order him off the pitch for treatment. But two minutes later the star striker who he was man-marking scores. You suddenly realise that you’d forgotten to wave the defender back on. The defender’s team are really angry, demanding the goal is disallowed (that you cancel the goal on the scoresheet).
What do you do?

You are the ref

Read the statements below and decide which is best. In this case, is it a goal or not?.
Allow the goal

Well done! This is the right answer.

You cannot disallow the goal. You’ll have to put up with all the criticism because you’ve made a serious mistake in not allowing the player back on. Fortunately this shouldn’t happen in the professional game because of the combination of the fourth official and the communication system. 

Keith Hackett: The rule about having to leave the field after receiving treatment is one that I would love to see changed. A few seasons ago, Thierry Henry was injured from a challenge which resulted in a penalty. Having received treatment, he was then forced to leave the field of play – meaning Henry, Arsenal’s penalty taker, couldn’t take the kick. What a nonsense.

Disallow the goal

Sorry. This is not the right answer.

You cannot disallow the goal. You’ll have to put up with all the criticism because you’ve made a serious mistake in not allowing the player back on. Fortunately this shouldn’t happen in the professional game because of the combination of the fourth official and the communication system.

Keith Hackett: The rule about having to leave the field after receiving treatment is one that I would love to see changed. A few seasons ago, Thierry Henry was injured from a challenge which resulted in a penalty. Having received treatment, he was then forced to leave the field of play – meaning Henry, Arsenal’s penalty taker, couldn’t take the kick. What a nonsense.

 

Leave a comment

Log in to leave a comment

Comentários

Ronal
12/04/2023
ES
40
points

Goal!


Ronal
12/04/2023 17:37
Spain
Manchester City
40

Goal!

Rath6180's picture
Rath6180
14/02/2023
GB
759
points

Fair enough - I would have disallowed the goal for my mistake.


Rath6180's picture
Rath6180
14/02/2023 09:47
United Kingdom
Liverpool
759

Fair enough - I would have disallowed the goal for my mistake.

hsn's picture
hsn
07/05/2022
TR
5521
points

When a player off the pitch for any reason like changing teared kit can't back on the ground without referee wave. During this time if a goal has been scored should be accepted.


hsn's picture
hsn
07/05/2022 15:43
Turkey
Tottenham Hotspur
5521

When a player off the pitch for any reason like changing teared kit can't back on the ground without referee wave. During this time if a goal has been scored should be accepted.

bao1960's picture
bao1960
12/02/2022
VN
419
points

I agree.


bao1960's picture
bao1960
12/02/2022 02:56
Vietnam
Manchester United
419

I agree.

Chris OM
04/12/2021
FR
53
points

I agree


Chris OM
04/12/2021 17:30
France
Manchester United
53

I agree

Gabriel Amaral's picture
Gabriel Amaral
05/04/2021
BR
1512
points

There's a lot of things that the officials should pay attention all the time, isn't it?


Gabriel Amaral's picture
Gabriel Amaral
05/04/2021 18:03
Brazil
Arsenal
1512

There's a lot of things that the officials should pay attention all the time, isn't it?

kayboy19's picture
kayboy19
14/10/2020
KH
95
points

fault from the assistant referee but it should be a goal


kayboy19's picture
kayboy19
14/10/2020 00:59
Cambodia
Liverpool
95

fault from the assistant referee but it should be a goal

josegsalass's picture
josegsalass
13/11/2019
VE
581
points

Unfortunately, a referee's mistake can cause damage to a team, they are humans, so that should be normal.


josegsalass's picture
josegsalass
13/11/2019 00:59
Venezuela
Liverpool
581

Unfortunately, a referee's mistake can cause damage to a team, they are humans, so that should be normal.

danimv4
13/08/2019
ES
52
points

Goal.


danimv4
13/08/2019 19:09
Spain
Liverpool
52

Goal.

Firas's picture
Firas
06/08/2019
IQ
25
points

Good


Firas's picture
Firas
06/08/2019 09:33
Iraq
Manchester United
25

Good

Firas's picture
Firas
06/08/2019
IQ
25
points

Good question


Firas's picture
Firas
06/08/2019 09:08
Iraq
Manchester United
25

Good question

Cityzen's picture
Cityzen
26/09/2018
GB
24
points

amazing


Cityzen's picture
Cityzen
26/09/2018 07:25
United Kingdom
Manchester City
24

amazing

fserrano121's picture
fserrano121
13/01/2018
CO
19
points

Excellent answer.


fserrano121's picture
fserrano121
13/01/2018 04:07
Colombia
Chelsea
19

Excellent answer.

mgsein
10/12/2017
MM
41
points

I got my answer right.


mgsein
10/12/2017 13:31
Myanmar
Manchester United
41

I got my answer right.

kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
02/07/2016
GH
4768
points

That's so right


kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
02/07/2016 11:24
Ghana
Manchester United
4768

That's so right

kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
02/07/2016
GH
4768
points

That's so right


kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
02/07/2016 11:15
Ghana
Manchester United
4768

That's so right

assemjuve's picture
assemjuve
04/04/2016
PS
3705
points

That is correct.


assemjuve's picture
assemjuve
04/04/2016 04:03
Palestinian Territory
Liverpool
3705

That is correct.

nikosonris
16/11/2015
UA
2453
points

Quite often we witness the situation when close to the end of the match a player of the winning side fall onto the pitch pretending to be injured and stretch the game. A few seconds later he is fit as a fiddle and gets no punishment. I would love to see it changed.


nikosonris
16/11/2015 13:30
Ukraine
Arsenal
2453

Quite often we witness the situation when close to the end of the match a player of the winning side fall onto the pitch pretending to be injured and stretch the game. A few seconds later he is fit as a fiddle and gets no punishment. I would love to see it changed.

raulito's picture
raulito
14/07/2014
PE
0
points

yes,I got my answer right


raulito's picture
raulito
14/07/2014 20:26
Peru
Chelsea
0

yes,I got my answer right

zoranik
27/05/2014
0
points

It's not a nonsense Keith. This rule doesn't alowe teams who are in lead and deffending (player can just lay down) to stretch the game and make it boring till the end...


zoranik
27/05/2014 15:27


0

It's not a nonsense Keith. This rule doesn't alowe teams who are in lead and deffending (player can just lay down) to stretch the game and make it boring till the end...

Leaderboard

Top Scorers
RankNameScore
1mobeckham6510
2Alex_from_Ukraine6278
3hsn5521
4wsanta5086
5kwesimanifest4768
6Liubomyr4408
7elghoul3988
8assemjuve3705
9aragorn19863557
10Gergő Nagy3396
Country ranking
RankNameScore
1Colombia71393
2Ukraine33261
3Spain27916
4Serbia27249
5Brazil23631
6Albania20578
7Vietnam19906
8Turkey19721
9Macedonia19074
10Bosnia and Herzegovina16333
Club ranking
RankNameScore
1Manchester United141170
2Liverpool109782
3Chelsea88300
4Arsenal85469
5Manchester City56704
6Tottenham Hotspur19024
7Newcastle United10456
8West Ham United7435
9Crystal Palace4224
10AFC Bournemouth4080

Level

4
Average: 4 (1 vote)

Goals

Learn about the difficult decisions a referee has to make.

Extension

By Keith Hackett and Paul Trevillion Copyright Guardian News and Media Ltd. 2010.