Club Profiles

AFC Bournemouth club badge
Arsenal
Aston Villa Club badge
Brentford badge
Brighton and Hove Albion club badge
Burnley FC club badge
Chelsea club badge
Crystal Palace badge
Everton
Liverpool badge
Manchester City badge
Manchester United badge
Newcastle United club badge
Nottingham Forest club badge
Sheffield United badge
Spurs badge
West Ham United
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Players collide.

Para Pemain Saling Berbenturan

Para Pemain Saling Berbenturan

Two players collide when they jump to head a high ball. One falls to the ground holding his head, so you call on the physio. But while you are waiting, you notice the big screen showing a replay: the player being treated had been viciously, deliberately elbowed by his opponent. The crowd go wild. Now that you have seen the incident on the replay, what should you do?

 

You are the ref

Read the statements below and decide which is best. In this case, what would you do?
You should punish the player!

Sorry, that's not right. As hard as it may be, no, you cannot take any action. 

Keith Hackett: You are not allowed to use the big screen in the decision-making process (and the screen should not have shown the incident). You should, though, communicate with your assistants to seek their view on the challenge – but if they’ve seen nothing wrong, that is the end of the matter. The situation would later be looked at by the FA, who could take it further if they were satisfied that none of the match officials had witnessed the elbowing.

You should ignore it and do nothing.

Well done.

Keith Hackett: You are not allowed to use the big screen in the decision-making process (and the screen should not have shown the incident). You should, though, communicate with your assistants to seek their view on the challenge – but if they’ve seen nothing wrong, that is the end of the matter. The situation would later be looked at by the FA, who could take it further if they were satisfied that none of the match officials had witnessed the elbowing.

 

Leave a comment

Log in to leave a comment

Komentar

Rath6180's picture
Rath6180
17/02/2023
GB
759
points

Certainly a booking incident and we have VAR now, so that doesn't sound right at all.


Rath6180's picture
Rath6180
17/02/2023 09:44
United Kingdom
Liverpool
759

Certainly a booking incident and we have VAR now, so that doesn't sound right at all.

hsn's picture
hsn
02/05/2022
TR
5533
points

This question about V.A.R system which wasn't applied then. The offensive player should be sent off by red card. After getting confirmation about position from the assistant referee.


hsn's picture
hsn
02/05/2022 14:00
Turkey
Tottenham Hotspur
5533

This question about V.A.R system which wasn't applied then. The offensive player should be sent off by red card. After getting confirmation about position from the assistant referee.

Taha Gashout's picture
Taha Gashout
12/04/2022
LY
492
points

That's awkward. The ref has seen it and will let the player to go away with it!. It doesnt matter how he checked the foul as long as the played committed a dangerous foul.


Taha Gashout's picture
Taha Gashout
12/04/2022 17:03
Libya
Liverpool
492

That's awkward. The ref has seen it and will let the player to go away with it!. It doesnt matter how he checked the foul as long as the played committed a dangerous foul.

Gabriel Amaral's picture
Gabriel Amaral
05/04/2021
BR
1512
points

Probably the VAR would help me, if I was the ref.


Gabriel Amaral's picture
Gabriel Amaral
05/04/2021 18:11
Brazil
Arsenal
1512

Probably the VAR would help me, if I was the ref.

Izabela
20/06/2020
BR
1505
points

Really?


Izabela
20/06/2020 04:55
Brazil
Newcastle United
1505

Really?

josegsalass's picture
josegsalass
18/11/2019
VE
581
points

That's right, referees´decision must be based on what they saw


josegsalass's picture
josegsalass
18/11/2019 02:51
Venezuela
Liverpool
581

That's right, referees´decision must be based on what they saw

danimv4
13/08/2019
ES
52
points

VAR.


danimv4
13/08/2019 19:10
Spain
Liverpool
52

VAR.

mgsein
10/12/2017
MM
41
points

Assistants are very important in these situation.


mgsein
10/12/2017 13:40
Myanmar
Manchester United
41

Assistants are very important in these situation.

srdjan91's picture
srdjan91
17/12/2016
RS
1
points

J


srdjan91's picture
srdjan91
17/12/2016 18:21
Serbia
Arsenal
1

J

kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
21/06/2016
GH
4768
points

in countries that have faulty screens the assistant referees will be of great importance


kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
21/06/2016 13:58
Ghana
Manchester United
4768

in countries that have faulty screens the assistant referees will be of great importance

kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
21/06/2016
GH
4768
points

that's the importance of the assistant referees


kwesimanifest's picture
kwesimanifest
21/06/2016 13:57
Ghana
Manchester United
4768

that's the importance of the assistant referees

assemjuve's picture
assemjuve
04/04/2016
PS
3705
points

Using the screen is not allowed and i think the idea of using it in the future is not good because the match will take longer time.


assemjuve's picture
assemjuve
04/04/2016 04:13
Palestinian Territory
Liverpool
3705

Using the screen is not allowed and i think the idea of using it in the future is not good because the match will take longer time.

HakanUslu1881's picture
HakanUslu1881
08/03/2016
TR
1761
points

That's reasonable.


HakanUslu1881's picture
HakanUslu1881
08/03/2016 08:02
Turkey
Leicester City
1761

That's reasonable.

nikosonris
16/11/2015
UA
2453
points

Interesting debate: whether to allow watching replays or not? On the one hand, it will definitely improve the quality of the decision-making process and really make it a 'fair play'. On the other hand, the human factor adds to the emotional sensitivity of a football match.


nikosonris
16/11/2015 13:09
Ukraine
Arsenal
2453

Interesting debate: whether to allow watching replays or not? On the one hand, it will definitely improve the quality of the decision-making process and really make it a 'fair play'. On the other hand, the human factor adds to the emotional sensitivity of a football match.

Abdallah
22/09/2015
KW
1814
points

Im not convinced in it


Abdallah
22/09/2015 20:25
Kuwait
Chelsea
1814

Im not convinced in it

noemi
31/05/2014
0
points

oops! learnt something today!


noemi
31/05/2014 18:10


0

oops! learnt something today!

greeh omer
27/05/2014
0
points

I will give the player who used foul yellow card and will be a free-kick against him


greeh omer
27/05/2014 19:33


0

I will give the player who used foul yellow card and will be a free-kick against him

aysu17
22/03/2013
0
points

what???:D


aysu17
22/03/2013 12:16


0

what???:D

Leaderboard

Top Scorers
RankNameScore
1mobeckham6510
2Alex_from_Ukraine6292
3hsn5533
4wsanta5086
5kwesimanifest4768
6Liubomyr4408
7elghoul3988
8assemjuve3705
9aragorn19863557
10Gergő Nagy3396
Country ranking
RankNameScore
1Colombia71520
2Ukraine33416
3Spain28630
4Serbia27294
5Brazil22773
6Albania20578
7Vietnam20022
8Turkey19886
9Macedonia19074
10Bosnia and Herzegovina16333
Club ranking
RankNameScore
1Manchester United142518
2Liverpool110076
3Chelsea89284
4Arsenal85416
5Manchester City57448
6Tottenham Hotspur19085
7Newcastle United10506
8West Ham United7536
9AFC Bournemouth4557
10Crystal Palace4470

Level

4
Average: 4 (1 vote)

Goals

Learn about the difficult decisions a referee has to make.

Extension

By Keith Hackett and Paul Trevillion
Copyright Guardian News and Media Ltd. 2010.